Tag Archives: murder

The messiness of crime [Crime & Punishment – Deuteronomy 21, part 4]

17 Jan

Crime and punishment is so complex, messy and often frustrating. The third season of the podcast Serial does an excellent job exploring the nuances of the criminal justice, as seen through the lens of Cleveland, Ohio. It likely comes as no surprise to you that we humans have a conflicted history of dealing with crime. In this series on Deuteronomy 21 it has been no different for the ancient nation of Israel. Through it all we have seen God’s heart for purity.  Even when a crime is committed and they don’t know who the guilty party is, Israel still needs to atone for it.  Purity in the land, and purity in his people is vital before God. 

This theme continues in verses 18-21.  Here again we have another one of those passages that is hard for us to hear with our modern sensibilities. Parents were to take extremely disobedient kids to the town elders, who will stone them to death. Whew! 

I think it is important to note that this is not just a regularly disobedient kid.  We all can remember when we were kids and didn’t do what our parents wanted us to do.  How many of you have stories?  I do.  There was the time my parents gave me 50 cents before church one Sunday. I was to put it in a Sunday School class offering.  But I kept it in my pocket instead of putting it in the offering plate.  After church, my family went home, and at some point that afternoon, I went outside to play.  I waited a few minutes, came back inside, and told my parents I found two quarters on the sidewalk!  I then asked if I could go around the corner to the local convenience store to buy a pack of baseball cards.  In high school I once lied to them about which movie I was going to see with some friends, and at the theater, the whole way through I couldn’t enjoy the movie because I felt so awful.  Maybe you know what I mean.

That is disobedience, but it was not all out rebellion.  What we are reading here in Deuteronomy 21 is all out rebellion.  It’s not just a few instances, or even a lot of disobedience. It is far worse, and there is no stopping it.  Also, we read that it involves drinking and drunkenness.  So we’re not talking about a child, but at the youngest, a teenager, and perhaps more likely a young adult.  The word “profligate” is used to describe this person, and that is not a word I use much or hear much.  The Hebrew word used there is sometimes translated “gluttonous”, sometimes translated “despicable.”  It refers to a person who is out of control.  So this is way more than disobedient.  This is a criminal.  The person is not just disrespecting or disobeying their parents, but all of society.  And the punishment is death. 

Again I say, Whew.  Death?  The ultimate punishment!  The death penalty.  Like the war passages we studied in the previous series, it is hard to know how to react to this.  Isn’t there some other way to respond than the death penalty?  Is there a possibility for rehabilitation?   Why such decisive, final action?  We know that God dearly values human life, but here we have an instance where he commands them to take life away.  Is God inconsistent? 

When compared to the holy war passage we studied last week, this command to give the death penalty to a profligate son is entirely consistent.  Last week we saw God’s heart to keep Israel pure by eradicating the land of nations that were declared evil.  That was evil outside Israel.  Here God is purging the evil from within.  God wants purity in the land. 

Take a look at that last statement in verse 21.  He says that when they give rebellious people the death penalty, it will serve as a deterrent for the rest of the nation.  Implied in this command is that other people will be afraid, and thus those others will want to be pure. 

We hear these kinds of arguments made for the use of the death penalty in our nation, that it removes evil and provides a deterrent for others, supposedly motivating them to be pure.  As with the disagreement about war, there is among Christians major disagreement about the death penalty, and about crime and punishment in general.  In any church, I’m sure some support the death penalty, and I’m sure some Christians do not. I’m sure we have people who are for jail and imprisonment and those who would like to have significant prison reform.  These are conflicted issues that we will not solve in this post.  Instead I’d like to try to seek God’s heart in this passage. First, we see that God desires that children obey their parents.  Second, he desires that evil is dealt with and restrained, and third, he desires that his people to live lives of purity.

This theme will continue in verses 22-23.  The situation of the evil son in verses 18-21 means that there will be some who are put to death by the death penalty.  The situation in verses 1-9 relates as well, because if the murderer is eventually found, murderers are to be put to death too.  Now here in verses 22-23 what we read is a death penalty that was enacted by hanging.  But similarly to the unsolved murder in verses 1-9 this hanging presents a problem.  What do you do with the body? 

God says, don’t let it hang overnight, bury it the same day.  Those hung, he adds, are under God’s curse.  Why would he say this?  Practically speaking, there could be a physical side to this as the body would start to decompose.  In fact, one scholar says, “A dead body is the primary source of ritual impurity in the Bible, and if it were left to decompose, its parts would eventually be scattered by birds and animals, spreading the impurity.”[1]

What is the principle behind it?  Once again: Do not desecrate the land. What does this teach us about God’s heart?  Purge the evil from you.  God is a God of purity and holiness.  In part 5, we’ll consider the implications of these principles for our lives.

[1] Ibid.

Bodies and wadis? [Crime & Punishment – Deuteronomy 21, part 2]

15 Jan

We have a murder on our hands! In part 1 of this series on crime and punishment in Deuteronomy 21, a dead body has been found. But the murderer can’t be found, or is thus far unknown.  God has told Israel that the body bring blood guilt on the land, and as we saw in part 1, he takes this very seriously. So God gives them a method to deal with the blood guilt in the land Deuteronomy chapter 21, verses 2-9.

Look at Verse 2.  The leaders of local towns are to measure the distance from the body to their various towns. This measurement would most likely happen by counting paces.  Is God saying that that the murder was committed by a person who lived in the town closest to the body?  No.  Again this is not about finding out who did it.  We are told that they don’t know who did it, and right now there is a more pressing issue: the body and blood spilled on the land.  What we are seeing here is the method Israel is to use to determine which town had jurisdiction to deal with the body.

Once they determine which town is closest to the body, then that town has to deal with the body and blood guilt.  This brings us to verses 3-4, and what have in these verses is something that has no exact parallel in the Old Testament Law. 

We are told they are to take a heifer, a cow that has never been worked, never worn a yoke.  Most likely that means it would be young, probably around 1 year old or so.  And they are to take that heifer out to a valley with unplowed, unplanted land, but with a flowing stream. This is called a wadi, which are common in the Middle East.  Many wadis have dry riverbeds that flow with water during the rainy season.  The wadis that are to be used for this ritual, however, are to have a constantly flowing stream.  Here’s the thing, though.  While there are many wadis in Israel, only very few have a constantly flowing stream.  Some towns are quite far from a wadi with a stream.  Why would God want them to perform a ritual in such a remote area? There is much speculation and very little agreement as to how to interpret this.  What is agreed upon though is found in the verses that describe the end of the ritual. Before they get to the end of the ritual, however, there are a few steps the elders of the town must perform.

First they are to break the heifer’s neck.  No easy task.  How do you break the neck of a cow?  Cows have huge necks! More importantly, though, why would God want them to break its neck?

God had already told Israel about a sacrificial procedure for the nation on what is called the Day of Atonement, where the sins of the nation would be placed on an animal that was sent outside the camp.  That animal was called the scapegoat.  The Day of Atonement scenario has echoes of what we read here in Deuteronomy 21, but this is different. 

The breaking of the heifer’s neck means there is no bloodshed, and further there is no altar.  That means this heifer with the broken neck is not being sacrificed.  There are plenty of passages in the OT Law that teach things like, “without the shedding of blood there is no remission of sins.”  But here there is no bloodshed.  What is going on here?

We have to continue on in the description to fully understand the meaning.  In verse 5, after the elders have broken the neck of the heifer, the priests step in as representatives of the Lord, but we are not told why.  Perhaps as representatives of God, for this ceremony to be official, they need to be there.  The people of that town, if they are serious about dealing with the purity of the land, and they do have a dead body on their land making the land impure, definitely want God’s approval for the purification ceremony, and apparently it requires the priests to be there.

So what is this ritual all about? We’ll explore that further next in part 3.

A biblical murder mystery? [Crime & Punishment – Deuteronomy 21, part 1]

14 Jan
Image result for murder mystery

Do you like crime dramas? Last year I watched a Netflix documentary called Making A Murderer.  It was gripping, often feeling like an extended episode of the TV show, Law & Order.  There were many interesting characters and plot twists, but in this documentary, all of it was real.  No actors.  Real interviews. Courtroom and TV news footage.  Making A Murderer follows the story of one family over the course of many years, as a police department investigates a murder, as the justice department builds a case, and eventually as suspects are convicted and thrown in prison.  But they appeal, and the appeal process takes time, and there are more court room scenes.  Surprisingly there is an acquittal.  Then there is another murder seemingly involving the same family, which leads to another investigation, court case, imprisonment and appeals.  The process is messy and expensive and time-consuming, and you never know what really happened.  I was glued to the screen.

In this series of posts in our study through Deuteronomy, we have three illustrations of crime and punishment, and the first one looks a lot like a murder mystery. 

If you’d like, see for yourself by reading Deuteronomy 21. What we are seeking is to learn more about God’s heart through his teaching to Israel about crime and punishment.

Look at verse 1, our first crime. As you can see, the text gives us a couple clues that this an unsolved murder case.  The first clue is the word “slain” at the beginning of the verse.  This is a vivid word in the Hebrew, better translated by our English word “pierced.”  It gives us the image of body that has been pierced by a sharp object, like a knife or sword.  The second clue that this is a murder is the phrase, “and it is not known who killed him,” at the end of the verse.  So we have a body that has been pierced and is dead, but we don’t know who did it. 

My mind immediately thinks: murder mystery!  I want to know more about this body and who did killed the person, and why.  But interestingly, the circumstances surrounding this death are barely in view in this passage.  There is no mention of tracking down the perpetrator, or anything like that.  It simply says, “it is not known who killed him,” which is vague.  We have no idea how much they investigated.  Was the body just found that day?  Have they been working this case for weeks?  We don’t get any details.  You might be thinking, but those are important details!  Shouldn’t God care about justice for the victim?  Absolutely, he does.  In fact he already dealt with that, as we will see below. 

God has another reason, however, for bringing up unsolved murders here in chapter 21.  Look at the middle of verse 1.  The body is found lying in a field, and yet notice how he describes the field.  It is “in the land the Lord their God is giving them to possess.”  That should sound familiar, because throughout our study of Deuteronomy we have heard a lot about the land. 

The land they are about to possess is the Promised Land, Canaan, the land of their forefathers, the land flowing with milk and honey.  God references the land 178 times in the book of Deuteronomy, and in all but three chapters.  I don’t know that it would be possible to overstate how important the land was to God and to the people.  For a people without land of their own, it is incredibly emotional when they obtain land.  Think about how you felt when you rented your first apartment or purchased your first house?  Overjoyed!  You had a space of your own.

So jump back with me to chapter 19, verse 10, as there is a mention of the land that connects to what God is talking about here in chapter 21.  In chapter 19, you might remember, God gives his people instructions for creating cities of refuge in the land.  People can flee to these cities if they have accidentally killed someone.  In those cities, they will be protected from any family members of the deceased who might want to take revenge on them.  And why?  Chapter 19, verse 10 tells us: “Do this so that innocent blood will not be shed in your land, which the Lord your God is giving you as your inheritance and so that you will not be guilty of bloodshed.”

In another place, Numbers 35:33-34, God teaches Israel something similar: “Do not pollute the land where you are. Bloodshed pollutes the land, and atonement cannot be made for the land on which blood has been shed, except by the blood of the one who shed it. Do not defile the land where you live and where I dwell, for I, the Lord, dwell among the Israelites.”

Teachings like these, and many others we have seen throughout Deuteronomy, illustrate how deeply God wanted purity in the land and in his people.  He not only wanted the physical land, the dirt, the earth, to be pure, but he also wanted the same for his people.  The Canaanites who were living in the land, though, did evil in God’s eyes.  They practiced the sacrificing of babies in worship, they were ruthless and murderous.  God wanted Israel to be different, to be holy and just, as he was.  So he is particular about purity.  There must be no innocent bloodshed.  When blood was shed, Numbers 35 tells us, the murderer must pay the blood guilt with his own blood (death penalty), and then God declares that the land will be pure again.  But what if the murderer can’t be found, or is unknown?  How will the blood guilt on the land be dealt with?  In other words, they still need to deal with the body!  So God gives them a method to deal with the blood guilt in the land when an unsolved murder happens Deuteronomy chapter 21, verses 2-9.

In part 2, we’ll examine what turns out to be a very strange ritual.